Item: Lanterns Season 1 Episode 4
Rating: 3.5
Author: Paul

What happens in Lanterns Episode 4, "The Weenie"

The season stops circling and answers its own question.

Hal visits Sinestro in his off-world prison. John gets an unannounced visit from Lianna, the Guardian who interviewed him. Hal and John then go looking for the Manhunter, and the hour ends by telling you who it is.

The title comes from Walt Disney's term for a visual landmark placed to draw people through a space, which is what John calls the building at the centre of Macon's ranch. It becomes a recurring double entendre.

Sinestro and the Guardians press the same fault line

Two parties spend this hour trying to separate Hal and John, from opposite directions and for different reasons.

Laura Linney as Lianna, a Guardian of the Universe in human form, standing in a motel room in a green coat and leather gloves. — Lianna turns up because John failed to check in, and leaves having done real damage. HBO / DC Studios

Sinestro tells Hal what to think about his trainee, and what to do about him. The suggestion is not oblique. Lianna arrives in John's motel room because he failed to check in, and uses the visit to tell him Hal broke his oath by making that trip. Neither of those is information delivered for its own sake.

Both target the same weakness, widening the divide even though neither man fully follows the instruction he is given. Zoe adds pressure by trying to get John out of Rushville. Antaan's group adds a deadline. Nobody in this episode makes anything easier.

What everyone in Lanterns actually wants

More is on the table than the show's reputation for withholding suggests.

The Guardians have said outright that John is there to replace Hal. Hal wants the Manhunter found and handed over. John wants to be a Lantern, and this episode gives him the season's clearest character beat: handed Hal's ring, he declines to say the oath and take the job that way.

That refusal is the most revealing thing he does. He has spent his life being aimed at this, his mother built a childhood around it, and when it is briefly available he will not take it by theft.

What remains unstated is Sinestro's real objective, and why the Manhunter has spent years reshaping Rushville. The principal characters' immediate objectives are otherwise reasonably clear.

Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre

The two of them are the show, and this hour gives them the most to do so far.

Kyle Chandler as Hal Jordan standing over Aaron Pierre as John Stewart, who is sitting on a grain silo walkway with a telescope. — The stakeout, and the funniest exchange the show has managed. HBO / DC Studios

The low blows land because you now know enough about both men for them to hurt, which would not have been true in Episode 1. The apology on the drive back is better still, because neither man is entirely honest during it and both know.

The lighter material works too. A conversation about flying, held while John is trying to watch a ranch through a telescope, is the funniest thing the show has done.

Two sequences that run far longer than they need to

Macon has John draw him, nude, in a staging borrowed directly from Titanic and Rose's portrait. Elsewhere, a confrontation plays out at length in a slaughterhouse.

Both scenes carry real information. The drawing establishes what Macon can make John do, that he knows about the affair, and the business about his cancer and who cured it. The slaughterhouse produces a decoy, a recording, a threat and a false accusation.

My problem is the time and the emphasis. The information could arrive in half the screen time, and Lianna's visit and the aftermath of Zoe's apparent death both deserved more of it. The tonal detour is the choice, not the content, and it is the choice this show keeps making when it has plot to move.

The jokes during the drawing are good. John telling Macon not to be stiff, Hal asking whether any of this is strictly necessary. They are funnier than the framing around them.

Ulrich Thomsen's Sinestro, second time out

His scene is the most productive conversation of the season. He gives Hal something concrete about how a Manhunter can be identified, then tells him what he thinks John represents. Both land.

The makeup does not survive a second look. In Episode 2 he appeared briefly and in low light, and read as strange. Given more screen time and better lighting, it reads as paint on a face.

Where Lanterns spends its effort

The show continues to choose restraint over scale, and this episode is not the argument against it I expected.

Kyle Chandler as Hal Jordan holding a retrieved satellite in a car park, a vehicle burning behind him. — The effects budget exists. This hour spends some of it. HBO / DC Studios

Hal flies to orbit, retrieves a weaponised satellite and throws a construct over the motel. John's drill gets its moment. The effects budget exists and this hour spends some of it. What the episode really invests in is rooms, conversations and psychological pressure.

That focus is a legitimate creative choice. Four episodes of predominantly small-scale staging are nonetheless starting to make a cosmic property feel visually confined.

Is Lanterns worth watching after four episodes?

Yes, and the nonlinear structure deserves more credit than it gets.

Telling the story out of order helps it function as a thriller and not a superhero action show. It also lets the series distribute its origin material across the timeline without forcing it all into an opening exposition dump.

The performances are strong and the writing is good. What keeps letting it down is judgement inside individual scenes.

Why Lanterns Episode 4 is a 3.5

Same score as the last two, which is now a pattern.

The reveal is good, the character work is the best it has been, and John's refusal of the ring is the strongest single beat of the season. Against that, two sequences absorb time the plot needed, the mostly small-scale staging is beginning to feel restrictive, and the episode's most theatrical moments are its least necessary.

The show is consistently good at what it is doing and consistently slowed by decisions inside individual scenes.

Lanterns Episode 4 verdict

The best episode for plot, and the one where the pacing hurts most.

Watch it for the reveal, for John turning down the thing he was raised to want, and for two actors who have found their double act. Then wonder how much better it might play with its two strangest sequences tightened.

The reveal. Zoe Macon is the Manhunter, and she is not dead. Hal asks John why he was not more upset when she died. John says he did not know, he just had a feeling.

Aaron Pierre as John Stewart and Poorna Jagannathan as Zoe Macon facing each other outside a motel room at night. — John says he only had a feeling. He did not want to accuse without certainty. HBO / DC Studios

Which reframes the affair. John slept with her without knowing she was William Macon's wife. His silence can be read as an instinct to protect her, though he tells Hal he only had a feeling and did not want to make the accusation without certainty.

The false name. The man at the slaughterhouse is Hector Gutiérrez, using Hector Hammond as an alias. The alias spends a long-standing Green Lantern villain's name on a one-scene deception, which is either a clean trick or a waste depending on whether the show comes back to it.

What Sinestro gives Hal. That when a Manhunter copies a carbon-based life form, its imperfect heart crystallises after death, exposing the disguise. Sinestro also explains that Manhunters are built to embed themselves in communities, locate weak points and manipulate anyone threatening their power.

The clue hidden in the conflicting accounts. Macon says Zoe nursed him until a male benefactor cured his cancer. Zoe later tells John that she saved his life herself. That discrepancy is the line connecting her to the benefactor, and it goes past without comment.

What has not happened yet. Hal identifies Zoe as the Manhunter, but nobody has performed the physical test Sinestro described. The identification rests on inference.

And the hospital. Rushville's hospital sits empty, and Macon's cancer was cured by someone. Together those details establish that the Manhunter's influence extends far beyond the present investigation.

Bright Bulbs

John is handed the ring and refuses to take the job by reciting the oath.
The Manhunter reveal, which reframes three episodes without cheating.
Sinestro's scene, the season's most productive conversation.
The telescope exchange, the show's funniest moment so far.

Dull Bulbs

Two sequences run at length when half the time would carry the same information.
Four episodes in, the series still feels visually confined for a cosmic property.
Sinestro's makeup falls apart once it is properly lit.

Shattered Bulbs

Nothing outright fails this week.

Cast

Aaron Pierre as John Stewart
Kyle Chandler as Hal Jordan
Jasmine Cephas Jones as Bernadette Stewart
J. Alphonse Nicholson as John Stewart Sr.
Laura Linney as Lianna
Kelly Macdonald as Kerry Kane

Created by Geeta Vasant PatelDrama Superhero Thriller Sci-FiGreen LanternDC2026TV-MAEnglish

About Paul

Paul

Movie & TV reviews

Paul is the pen name of the person who writes ShatteredBulbs. Paul has spent about 15 years watching films, series and documentaries closely, mostly to understand them: who the characters are, what they want, and why they do what they do. And sometimes just to watch Godzilla fight Kong.