How Realistic Is War? What English Divorce Law Says About Carla and Morgan

War's divorce is great TV. What English law says about the affair, the prenup, the fight over Zephyr, the mole and Carla's claim, and how much is real.

Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) stands in the witness box as Prudence Mutti (Archie Panjabi), holding a folder, points across the courtroom.

Justin Downing / Sky / HBO

In this piece · 11 sections

This piece covers all eight episodes of War Season 1, including how the divorce ends. It explains the law in England and Wales using the publicly available sources listed at the end: legislation, court judgments, official guidance and published reporting. Nothing here is legal advice; it's general information, and anyone who needs advice about their own situation should speak to a qualified family lawyer.

War gets the outline of a big London divorce right and most of its dirtiest moves wrong. Mediation, arbitration, a fight over a prenup (an agreement made before marriage) and barristers arguing in front of a judge are all real. But under English law, the affair would barely count and the mole could get his firm into serious trouble. And the question the finale turns on matters less than the show makes it look: whether Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) helped build Zephyr, the social network run by her husband, Morgan Henderson (Dominic West).

I watched War for the entertainment, and I said as much in my review of War Season 1. A lot of the legal side looked fake to me. So this piece checks which parts hold up.

Does Morgan's affair matter in an English divorce?

Not for getting divorced. Since 6 April 2022, couples in England and Wales have been able to divorce without blaming each other. Before that, a spouse had to show the marriage had broken down using one of five facts, and adultery was one of them. Couples relying on separation generally had to wait two years if both agreed, or five years if not.

So Carla doesn't need evidence of an affair to get divorced. In Episode 1, she arranges for her friend Flora Monroe (Rose Williams) to test whether Morgan will cheat, and he does. Real family lawyers spotted the problem. Speaking to the Law Society Gazette, Sarah Jane Boon of Charles Russell Speechlys said that whether Morgan committed adultery, and how Carla got evidence of it, would not be relevant to a divorce under no-fault law. How someone gets evidence can still have consequences of its own, which comes up again with the mole.

The money is a separate question. When a judge divides a couple's wealth, the law lists what they must consider, and conduct is on the list, but only if it would be "inequitable to disregard it", meaning unfair to ignore. Courts read that narrowly. The behaviour usually has to be "gross and obvious" before it changes the outcome. Bad behaviour during the case itself, such as refusing to negotiate sensibly, can be reflected in an order to pay legal costs, though that is for the judge to decide.

My view: the affair does matter to some extent. Carla wasn't happy in the marriage, and she believed Morgan had cheated before. But if she helped Zephyr grow in its early days, that should decide the money, and the affair shouldn't change it. Under English law, the affair itself would be very unlikely to change the financial award.

What would an English court do with Zephyr?

English judges aim for a fair result. In White v White in 2000, the House of Lords said there should be no bias in favour of the spouse who brought in the money over the one who looked after the home, and that judges should check their decisions against a "yardstick of equality". The law itself counts "looking after the home or caring for the family" as a contribution.

Serena Byrne (Phoebe Fox), Nicholas Taylor (James McArdle) and Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) sit in a wood-panelled courtroom, with a woman watching from the row behind.
Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) in court in the finale with her solicitors, Serena Byrne (Phoebe Fox) and Nicholas Taylor (James McArdle). Miya Mizuno / Sky / HBO

In July 2025, the Supreme Court confirmed in Standish v Standish that matrimonial property, meaning what a couple made or gained during the marriage and because of it, is shared, with equal division as the starting point. Property one spouse owned before the marriage, or inherited, generally falls outside that sharing. It can still be used to meet needs, and the way a couple treats an asset over time can bring it into the shared pot.

So the legal fight over Zephyr isn't really about who did the work. What matters is when and how Zephyr came about. War knows this. In Episode 5, Carla lets slip that she named Zephyr after a poem, and her lawyers seize on it to argue the company came out of the marriage. They picked the right fight.

If Zephyr belongs to the marriage, the starting point is that Carla gets half the value of what the marriage built, whether or not she brought in a single subscriber. That doesn't have to mean half the shares. A court could leave Morgan with Zephyr and give Carla other assets or money instead. Taking half of Morgan's shares is the deal the two of them choose for themselves in the finale.

Morgan could try to argue for more than half by claiming a "special contribution". In Work v Gray in 2017, the Court of Appeal said the question is whether one spouse's contribution was so exceptional that it would be inequitable to disregard the difference between them. The bar is high: lawyers in that case could identify only three cases in the 12 years after an earlier leading case, Lambert v Lambert, where the argument had produced an unequal split. In one of them, Charman v Charman, the husband kept 63.5% of the assets, partly because the assets he kept carried greater risk.

Would Morgan and Carla's prenup hold up in England?

Prenups aren't automatically binding in England and Wales, but they carry real weight. Since the Supreme Court's 2010 ruling in Radmacher v Granatino, a court should give effect to a prenup that both people signed freely, understanding what it meant, unless, in the circumstances when the court looks at it, it would not be fair to hold them to it. The same ruling says a prenup can't be allowed to harm the reasonable needs of any children of the family.

Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) rests a hand on the shoulder of Gabriel Duval (Aran Murphy) as they face each other in a dim room.
Gabriel Duval (Aran Murphy) and Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) in Episode 3. Sam Taylor / Sky / HBO

In Episode 2, Morgan acknowledges that his earnings have grown and that he and Carla live very differently from when they signed the prenup. Carla's lawyers see a way to challenge it. Under its terms, they argue, she couldn't maintain the lifestyle they now share. At the arbitration in Episode 3, they also argue that Carla's son, Gabriel Duval (Aran Murphy), is in effect Morgan's son, and Morgan's lead lawyer, St John Smallwood (Pip Torrens), tells him to say he isn't Gabriel's father.

The Gabriel argument raises two separate questions. Under English law, a stepchild whom both spouses treated as part of their family counts as a "child of the family", and a court has the power to order support for that child. In deciding, it looks at whether the stepparent took on responsibility for the child's upkeep, on what basis and for how long, whether he knew the child wasn't his own, and whether anyone else has a legal duty to support the child. Whether the prenup should stand is a further question. Morgan treating Gabriel as his son wouldn't sink the agreement by itself. On that argument, the question is whether holding Carla to the prenup would leave Gabriel's reasonable needs unmet.

The arbitrator throws the prenup out. Under the rules, fairness can outweigh a prenup, so that outcome is possible.

The rules may change. From June to August 2026, the government consulted on reforms that include making "qualifying nuptial agreements" binding if safeguards are met. Those are proposals, and the law hasn't changed yet.

What I think Carla deserved

Leave the law aside for a moment. In the finale, Carla tells the court that in Zephyr's early days she signed up famous friends and got a co-star's film promoted on the platform, and she credits that with Zephyr's first million subscribers. What it grew into after that, she says, is Morgan's work. Her barrister, Joy "Budgie" Budge (Celia Imrie), points the court to a list of Zephyr's first subscribers.

Morgan's barrister, Prudence Mutti (Archie Panjabi), objects that having celebrity friends doesn't make Carla a founder. In cross-examination, she quizzes Carla on Zephyr's senior staff and revenue, and Carla answers that she never claimed to run the business day to day. What nobody settles is how many of the first million users came because of her. Like a lot of War, that part is left to your imagination.

As the show portrays it, if her story is true, she deserved half. A social network lives or dies on whether people use it, and plenty of social media and messaging apps have died because not enough people signed up. Compare a social network starting out in 2001. As I see it, a slow start was survivable back then: there was less competition, and the technology wasn't the main problem. By the 2010s, everything moved much faster, and lots of companies copied whatever new thing someone built. Building the product is one part of the job. You also have to build a brand and bring in users, and those two things matter most at the start, taking a platform from zero to one, then from one to ten, then from ten to a hundred. If Carla gave Zephyr that first push, she deserved half, definitely.

The other side has a fair argument too. Carla only claims half because they're divorcing; if the marriage had lasted, she wouldn't have asked for it. And I'm not sure the number should be 50%. Plenty of celebrities become co-founders of products without being involved in the day-to-day running or the finances. Something like 25% might be fairer for that kind of role.

English law looks at both points differently. Divorce opens the door for either spouse to ask the court for a financial order, so making the claim then is how the system works. And if Zephyr is matrimonial property, Carla's claim to share in its value doesn't depend on how hands-on she was in running it. The law's starting point is more generous to Carla than my business logic.

How realistic are War's mediation and arbitration scenes?

The structure is real. In England and Wales, if a couple can't agree about money, the spouse who applies to court for a financial order usually has to see a mediator first, at a mediation information and assessment meeting, or MIAM. Couples who already agree can apply for a consent order without one. The court rules also say judges expect couples to try at least one out-of-court option first, unless there are safety concerns or another good reason.

Alanda Brown (Amara Karan), in a brown suit, holds a door handle as she looks into a room.
The mediator, Alanda Brown (Amara Karan), in Episode 2. Miya Mizuno / Sky / HBO

For much of the mediation in Episode 2, the two sides sit on different floors, with the mediator, Alanda Brown (Amara Karan), carrying offers between them, and a Cathcarts lawyer calls the other side the "enemy on the third floor". Splitting the parties into separate rooms is a real format called shuttle mediation, where the mediator moves between them.

Arbitration is real too. Since 2012, couples have been able to hire a specialist family arbitrator to decide money disputes privately under English law, through a scheme run by the Institute of Family Law Arbitrators. Both sides agree in advance to accept the decision, and they can ask a court to turn it into an order. The court keeps the final say: since Haley v Haley in 2020, a party can challenge an award on the basis that it was wrong, much as they could appeal a judge's decision.

What didn't convince me was the drama around it. A lot of the mediation and court scenes are over the top, which suits a show built to entertain.

Could a real law firm get away with War's mole?

Cathcarts get Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux) hired at Taylor & Byrne so he can spy for them. Over the season he sends Cathcarts Taylor & Byrne's own profit-and-loss statement and a photo of a draft of Carla's asset list. (The full story of Johnny Warren covers everything he does.) In real life, that would be a disaster for everyone involved.

Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux) faces Saeed Masood (Shaheen Jafargholi) in a dim office corridor.
Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux) and Saeed Masood (Shaheen Jafargholi) in Episode 6. Sam Taylor / Sky / HBO

English courts have dealt with snooping in divorces before. In Imerman v Tchenguiz in 2010, a wife's brother copied her husband's documents from a computer server in an office they shared. The Court of Appeal ruled that this kind of "self-help" was unlawful, a breach of confidence the courts would not condone, even when one side feared the other would hide assets. Whether material obtained that way can be used as evidence is a separate question, which the judge decides.

Solicitors also have their own code of conduct. It requires them to keep clients' affairs confidential unless the client consents or the law requires or permits disclosure, and it says they must not mislead anyone or tamper with evidence. Leaking Carla's draft asset list goes straight to client confidentiality and honesty. Taking Taylor & Byrne's accounts breaches the firm's own confidence, not a client's.

The show's other tricks raise their own problems. Budgie has Taylor & Byrne delete Carla's correspondence about the honey trap and get her to send it again, so the file shows the firm objected. The solicitors who recreate the file answer to the solicitors' code, with its rules against misleading people and tampering with evidence. Budgie, who tells them to do it, is a barrister, and the Bar Standards Board's core duties require her to act with honesty and integrity.

Then there's Flora. When her mother threatens to go to the papers, the firm pays for a conservatory at her house and Flora signs a non-disclosure agreement. The Solicitors Regulation Authority's warning notice says a non-disclosure agreement must not be used to stop someone making a disclosure the law requires. Paying for confidentiality isn't the same as paying for a witness's silence, so the real questions would be what the agreement tried to keep quiet and whether the money depended on what Flora said. In the finale, Flora gives evidence.

I'd be surprised if a reputable firm tried something like Johnny, though I can't rule it out.

Would War's divorce really play out in public?

Reporters could do more than wait outside, but they might not be allowed to name anyone. In Episode 1, a character predicts this will be the biggest divorce trial in British history, and in the finale the press waits outside court. In England and Wales, financial cases in the family courts usually take place in private. As a 2024 family court ruling explains, that means the public has no right to be there. Accredited journalists and legal bloggers are an exception, and have long been able to attend most private hearings.

Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) and Prudence Mutti (Archie Panjabi) climb the court steps past police officers and a crowd of photographers.
Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) and his barrister, Prudence Mutti (Archie Panjabi), arrive at court past photographers and police. Justin Downing / Sky / HBO

The bigger question is what they could publish. Since 29 January 2025, a pilot covering financial cases in every court in England and Wales has let them report what they see, within limits. When a reporter attends, the judge considers making a transparency order setting out what can be published, and can direct that there be no reporting at all. The standard order bars publishing the couple's names, their children's names and the identity of their businesses. Unless the judge changed that, a report on a real case like this one couldn't name Carla, Morgan or Zephyr. Reporters can't attend the settlement meetings known as FDR hearings, and the pilot has been extended to 29 January 2027.

How realistic is the ending of War?

In the finale, Morgan and Carla settle between themselves before the judge rules. Carla gets half of Morgan's Zephyr shares and monthly payments until he retires. They also agree that Morgan will keep spending time with Gabriel.

Settling is realistic. Couples can agree the money themselves and ask a judge to turn the deal into a consent order, made in the agreed terms based on the information they provide. The judge approves it if they think it's fair, and can ask for changes if not. The law also tells the court to consider a clean break, ending the couple's financial ties as soon as it's just and reasonable. Ongoing payments are still allowed where they're appropriate, which is why the retirement end date matters: it puts a limit on how long Morgan keeps paying.

Then there's Gabriel. He's 16, and in England and Wales a court won't normally make a new order about where a child lives or who they spend time with once they reach 16, unless the circumstances are exceptional. If a court does have to settle a dispute over those arrangements, it must consider the child's wishes and feelings in the light of their age and understanding. So arrangements for Gabriel would rest on what Morgan and Carla agree, and at his age Gabriel would have a big say.

So is War realistic?

The skeleton is real, and most of the weapons aren't. The steps Morgan and Carla go through, from mediation and arbitration to barristers cross-examining witnesses in court, all exist. The prenup fight and the argument over whether Zephyr is a product of the marriage are questions real lawyers would argue about. The honey trap would make no difference to getting divorced, and the mole and the recreated file could get the people involved into serious trouble.

Real divorce law isn't simple either. In December 2024, the Law Commission, which advises the government on law reform, concluded that the law on dividing money after divorce is uncertain and hard for most couples to understand, and the government has since consulted on changes. War doesn't fix that, and it doesn't try to. War is built to entertain, and on that it delivers.

For who comes out ahead once the dust settles, read who wins the divorce in War.

Disclaimer

This article is general information about the law of England and Wales only. It was written from the publicly available sources listed below, as they stood on 22 November 2026, and the law can change. None of it is legal advice, and every divorce turns on its own facts. If you're going through a divorce or separation, speak to a qualified family lawyer.

Sources

About Paul

Paul

Movie & TV reviews

Paul is the pen name of the person who writes ShatteredBulbs. Paul has spent about 15 years watching films, series and documentaries closely, mostly to understand them: who the characters are, what they want, and why they do what they do. And sometimes just to watch Godzilla fight Kong.

All of Unscrewed →