In this piece · 9 sections
- Why War has no lead
- What do the lawyers in War want?
- How did the lawyers in War try to win?
- What did the war cost Morgan and Carla?
- Who wins the divorce in War?
- The case for Morgan and Carla
- Do Morgan and Carla get back together in War?
- Why War doesn't make its lawyers look bad
- What this means for War Season 2
This piece covers all eight episodes of War Season 1, finale included.
On paper, Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) wins the divorce. She walks away from Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) with half of his shares in Zephyr, monthly payments until he retires, and the two of them agree to share access to her son, Gabriel Duval (Aran Murphy). But the side that comes out ahead is the lawyers: both firms claim a victory for a settlement Morgan and Carla agreed without them, and the people who ran the war at both firms walk away from everything they did along the way.
Why War has no lead
The posters and the setup sell Morgan and Carla as the leads, and their divorce drives everything forward. They don't do the heavy lifting, though. In a divorce case, the lawyers pick everything up, and War is about that. What we get from the couple is their reactions: their expressions, their feelings, what they are thinking and what they let show.
The format backs this up. War was built as an anthology about two rival London law firms, Cathcarts and Taylor & Byrne, with a different case each season. Both firms return for Season 2, and the season ends with them. Morgan and Carla get a walk on a beach in France and hot chocolate with Gabriel, but the last scene is back at Taylor & Byrne, where Serena Byrne (Phoebe Fox) goes into labour and her husband and partner, Nicholas Taylor (James McArdle), hurries her into the lift. If Morgan and Carla were the leads, it would have ended on the beach.
What do the lawyers in War want?
Every lawyer in War has something riding on the case beyond the client. Taylor & Byrne is a young firm, run by a married couple, and by Episode 4 it is short of money. At Cathcarts, the old, established firm, the senior associate David Schill (Miles Jupp) has his sights set on partnership. Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux), the young lawyer Cathcarts plant inside Taylor & Byrne, wants his career back after whatever went wrong for him in New York.
The show presents the lawyers as caring about Morgan and Carla, and some of them seem to. But to me, the goal for all of them is financial, and they are out for themselves.
How did the lawyers in War try to win?
Cathcarts, acting for Morgan, start before the case does. They plant Johnny inside Taylor & Byrne with a glowing reference from Schill's friend in New York, and Morgan only learns about it afterwards. Johnny spends the season feeding Cathcarts the other side's plans. (The full story of Johnny Warren covers how it works and how he is caught.) When he warns them that Carla's lawyers will argue Morgan has become Gabriel's de facto father, St John Smallwood (Pip Torrens), Morgan's lead lawyer, tells Morgan to stand up at the arbitration in Episode 3 and say he isn't Gabriel's father, though Morgan raised the boy. In Episode 4, Smallwood uses Nicholas's stammer against him and tears up a letter Morgan writes to Carla. In Episode 5, he sends Morgan to dinner with Gabriel, Cathcarts make sure a photographer catches the two of them hugging outside, and Gabriel decides Morgan set it up.

Taylor & Byrne, acting for Carla, are more polite about it and no cleaner. Carla sent her friend Flora Monroe (Rose Williams) to seduce Morgan, a plan she had raised with Serena and Nicholas before she went through with it. Their barrister, Joy "Budgie" Budge (Celia Imrie), has them delete the correspondence and get Carla to send it again, so the file shows the firm objected straight away. When Flora's mother threatens to go to the press, the firm pays for a conservatory at her house, and Flora signs a non-disclosure agreement.
Then, in Episode 7, the two firms do a deal with each other. Cathcarts had spent Episode 6 hunting for proof of the honey trap. Now Taylor & Byrne have the mole's phone, Cathcarts know about the payment to Flora, and either story could finish the other firm. So Serena and Smallwood agree to bury both ("forget Johnny. You never heard of him."), and in the same deal they agree to settle the case between themselves. That deal protects the two firms, whatever it does for Morgan and Carla. To me, both legal teams are the worst. They know they have messed up, and they are covering themselves.
What did the war cost Morgan and Carla?
Morgan and Carla aren't innocent. Morgan sleeps with Flora, Carla set the trap, and the show implies she has had affairs of her own. But they were finding their footing, and the lawyers made it worse. The husband and wife were taxed for it.
Carla confides in Johnny and sleeps with him, with no idea he is working for her husband's lawyers. Gabriel ends up a pawn: Morgan is told to deny being his father, then sent to dinner with him for a photograph, and Gabriel thinks Morgan set it up. Morgan tells Smallwood off for using his son, but the damage is done. Saeed Masood (Shaheen Jafargholi), a junior at Taylor & Byrne, is walked out of the building for a leak Johnny framed him for. And the honey trap comes out anyway. The firms agreed to bury it in Episode 7, but the story breaks in the press at the start of the finale, and Flora ends up on the stand.
As Johnny tells Flora in the finale: "It is impossible to be a good lawyer and a good person." Flora doesn't accept it. "That's not true," she tells him: she is an actress, she faces the same choice, and all you can do is live your own way. George Kay, who created the show, told Variety that Johnny's whole story is wrapped around that question.
Who wins the divorce in War?
Morgan and Carla settle it themselves in the finale. The letter Smallwood tore up reaches the courtroom, read out by Flora, and in it Morgan wants to end things "without these lawyers coming between us". Before the judge can rule, he pulls Carla aside and they agree the terms between the two of them.

Then the lawyers take the credit. One of them puts the plan plainly: "we'll announce that as a massive win." Outside court, Beatrice "Queen Bea" Ubosi (Nina Sosanya) of Cathcarts tells the press, "we are delighted by today's outcome", Serena says Carla has done better than even she could have hoped, and Carla's side thanks Morgan for "seeing sense". Taylor & Byrne also hear that the firm's costs have been covered.
When the lawyers announce that everyone won, it is hilarious. Honestly, the lawyers won. For a lot of what happened, it felt like nobody had to bear the consequences.
The case for Morgan and Carla
Morgan and Carla have a case of their own. They cut the lawyers out at the last minute, chose the terms themselves, and kept Morgan in Gabriel's life. Common sense prevailed, of sorts.
Whether Carla deserved half is harder to say. At first it felt to me like she got a lot more than she deserved, and for most of the season the show doesn't make it clear why she should get so much. But War leaves a lot to the viewer's imagination, and it does that with a lot of things. Carla believes Morgan has had other affairs, but apart from Flora, the show never shows one. You can assume they had a happy life and she was practically a founding member of Zephyr, or you can assume the opposite.
The finale gives her side of it. Carla tells the court that early on she signed up famous friends and got a co-star's film promoted on the platform, which she credits with Zephyr's first million subscribers, while what it grew into after that is Morgan's work. Budgie backs part of it up with a list of Zephyr's first subscribers, which includes the co-star and writers, musicians and actors with big followings. Morgan's barrister, Prudence Mutti (Archie Panjabi), answers that having celebrity friends doesn't make Carla a founder. And the list can't show how many of the first million those friends brought in. Morgan may well have run brand campaigns of his own, and I doubt all of that growth was organic.
If her story is true, half makes sense. Imagine a huge pop star telling their fans to move to a new platform: millions would sign up that same day, and the servers might crash. Influence is that powerful. Carla isn't that famous, but a social network lives on the network effect, and a rush of sign-ups at the start is a huge thing. If she really brought those people in, she deserved it, and in that sense her 50% of Morgan's shares was fair. The settlement made sense to me.
Even so, look at what it took to get there. The wish that ends the case, Morgan wanting Carla to leave with her fair share, was written down in Episode 4, and his own lawyer tore it up. Between that letter and the deal they made on their own came a photographer, a framed junior, the mole's exposure and a public scandal. The couple won the terms. The lawyers won the war.
Do Morgan and Carla get back together in War?
No. They settle, part on friendly terms, and walk together on the beach in Normandy where they first fell in love. George Kay has said they are still a loving family, but "no longer a couple". I don't think they should get back together. A lot has gone on, and they said a lot to each other, but they still have love for each other and they are friendly. Over time, people get dragged down by the weight of the negativity around them, and it can cause serious problems in their lives. Basically, that happened to Morgan and Carla. They went through a lot, and they were able to separate amicably in the end, which was good. They are more the kind of couple who get together at Christmas.
Why War doesn't make its lawyers look bad
The clever part is that most viewers won't come away thinking the lawyers were bad. The show makes them enjoyable. Smallwood is really smart, and it is great to watch a lawyer nobody can take advantage of easily. Serena and Nicholas are a married couple building their own firm, with a baby on the way.
The lawyers made things worse in such a way that you don't hold it against them. The show is constructed that well.
What this means for War Season 2
Morgan and Carla's story is finished. The firms' isn't. Season 2 has already been filmed, and it moves Cathcarts and Taylor & Byrne on to what Sky and HBO call "an explosive defamation case", with Avery Reed (Marisa Tomei), Jo MacNeil (Kelly Macdonald), Jefferson Allen (David Harewood) and Elliott Wyatt (Richard Schiff). Wyatt shares his name with the New York lawyer Cathcarts used to vouch for Johnny, and Kay has said Johnny comes back to pay for his Season 1 decisions. No release date has been announced.
The finale leaves the firms with plenty to carry over: Serena's baby, Johnny's unanswered request for another chance, and Saeed, who lost his job for something he didn't do. My full review of War Season 1 covers the rest of the season.
