In this piece · 9 sections
- Who is Johnny Warren in War?
- How did Cathcarts plant Johnny at Taylor & Byrne?
- What does Johnny do as the mole?
- How is Johnny caught in War?
- What happens to Johnny after he is exposed?
- What happens to Johnny at the end of War?
- Should Serena give Johnny another chance?
- Is Johnny in War Season 2?
- What I make of Johnny Warren
This explainer covers the whole of War Season 1, finale included.
The mole in War is Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux), a young lawyer planted inside Taylor & Byrne, which represents Carla Duval (Sienna Miller), by Cathcarts, the firm acting for her husband, Morgan Henderson (Dominic West). He is exposed at the end of Episode 6, shut out by his firm and his girlfriend in Episode 7, and ends the finale asking Serena Byrne (Phoebe Fox) for another chance, with no answer. He is coming back in Season 2.
Who is Johnny Warren in War?
Johnny is a London lawyer who has come home after three years at Wyatt-Wren, a Manhattan firm he calls "one of New York's standout firms". Something went wrong there. His girlfriend, Bella Croft (Honor Swinton Byrne), tells him in Episode 1 that they are back in London because he messed up in New York. Episode 6 adds one detail: he signed a legal document he should never have signed, and as he tells it, the firm threw him under the bus. The season never says what the document was. Sky's own character page says only that a mistake in his New York job "continues to cast a shadow over his career".

When the season opens, he is waiting tables in an expensive bar and chasing interviews. One senior partner tells him that Wyatt-Wren remember his time there as "less of a triumph than you seem to recall". At Cathcarts, he all but begs David Schill (Miles Jupp), a senior associate: "Do not let me walk out of that door."
How did Cathcarts plant Johnny at Taylor & Byrne?
Cathcarts take Johnny on in secret and send him to work for the other side. Late in Episode 1, St John Smallwood (Pip Torrens), Morgan's lead lawyer, hands over to Schill to explain the trick to Morgan, who only learns about it then. Before Cathcarts took Johnny on, Schill rang a friend in New York, Elliott Wyatt, for a reference. He had told Johnny at the interview that he knew Wyatt. The reference was decent, so Schill got Wyatt to promise a far better reference to any other firm that called about Johnny.
Taylor & Byrne called. At Johnny's interview, Serena says they spoke to "Elliott Wyatt, the son", who put Johnny's weak spots down to insecurity more than inexperience, and she offers him a junior associate's job on the Duval divorce. At Cathcarts, Beatrice "Queen Bea" Ubosi (Nina Sosanya) checks that their mole is definitely in place, and Schill confirms the arrangement in one line: "Except he really works for us."
What does Johnny do as the mole?
His time as the mole runs through six episodes:
- Episode 2, "No More Nasty Surprises". Flora Monroe (Rose Williams), the friend Carla sent to test Morgan, is asked to sign a non-disclosure agreement, and her mother demands £20,000 for the signature. Johnny volunteers to deal with it and comes back with a deal: Flora signs, and her mother gets the full amount. Her mother insists on the money first, and Johnny agrees. Flora doesn't want the cash, so Johnny suggests getting the money to her mother some other way, and in the end Taylor & Byrne pay for a conservatory at her mother's house, with Johnny making the payment. He tells Serena that Flora "took the money and then signed the NDA, just like we wanted." By the end of the episode, Cathcarts have a recording of that report. At home, Bella teases him: "God, you'd make a bad spy!"
- Episode 3, "Chip Off the Block". He tells Schill that Carla's lawyers will argue Morgan has become the de facto father of Carla's son, Gabriel Duval (Aran Murphy), which would make the prenup out of date. Before the arbitration, Smallwood tells Morgan to say he isn't Gabriel's father.
- Episode 4, "Sing". He photographs Taylor & Byrne's profit-and-loss statement for Cathcarts. At the end of the episode, Carla kisses him, with no idea who he really works for.
- Episode 5, "Every Little Thing She Does". He and Carla sleep together. He also photographs a draft of Carla's asset list and sends it to Cathcarts, without noticing that it still carries a mistake.
- Episode 6, "The Simple Act of Paying Attention". He covers his tracks by framing a colleague, and gets caught anyway (below).
- Episode 7, "The Juicy Bit". Cornered, he tries to use Flora to save himself (below).
How is Johnny caught in War?
Two slips catch him: a joke exposes the leak, and a quote exposes the leaker. A joke of Carla's about a Ferrari Testarossa was typed into her asset list by mistake and later corrected, and Johnny sent Cathcarts the uncorrected draft. When the Testarossa turns up in Cathcarts' paperwork, Taylor & Byrne know their own files have leaked, and the mole hunt begins.

Johnny's first move is to tell Molly Giordano (Emma Laird) and Saeed Masood (Shaheen Jafargholi), the other two juniors who handled the list, to keep it between the three of them. His second is to frame Saeed. An email signed "S" confesses to Cathcarts: "I confess I have sent you materials I should never have disclosed." Johnny wrote it from Saeed's computer, and Saeed, who did nothing wrong, is walked out of the building by security.
Meanwhile, Johnny turns on his own side. When Schill stops answering, Johnny leaves him a voicemail threatening to blow the case wide open unless Cathcarts protect him. Schill hands the problem to Smallwood, who takes over as Johnny's contact and acts as though the arrangement never existed. When they meet, Johnny tries to record the conversation, and Smallwood asks for his phone and finds it recording. He still dangles a way back: bring proof of the honey trap before the trial, "and you could rescue your career." Johnny goes through Carla's messages with Flora, deleted ones included, and finds nothing that proves anything.
The quote finishes him. He repeats Schill's favourite line, a Keanu Reeves quote that gives Episode 6 its title: "The simple act of paying attention can take you a long way." Serena knows exactly where he got it.
What happens to Johnny after he is exposed?
In Episode 7, it all falls apart, and Taylor & Byrne lock him out of his email, his accounts and the building. He tries to steal the receipt for the conservatory, which would prove Carla's side paid Flora, and his former colleagues snatch it back. Then he goes to Flora and tries to get her to side with Morgan and go to Cathcarts, even though she has signed to keep quiet, and she sees through him.
At home, Nicholas Taylor (James McArdle) is waiting on the sofa. Nicholas has told Bella about the spying, and he warns Johnny about criminal charges. Johnny hands over his second phone, and when Schill rings it, Nicholas answers: "Johnny can't come to the phone right now, David." Bella tells Johnny he messed up in New York and has done it again here, and not to be there when she gets back.
The two firms, meanwhile, settle their own score. Taylor & Byrne hold Johnny's phone, Cathcarts know about the conservatory, and each could ruin the other, so Serena and Smallwood agree to bury both stories. "We're saying forget Johnny," they agree. "You never heard of him."
What happens to Johnny at the end of War?
The finale, "Partners", gives Johnny a better ending than anything before it suggested, and it starts with a theft. In Episode 4, Morgan wrote Carla a letter and Smallwood tore it up. Now Johnny snoops around Smallwood's office at Cathcarts, finds the letter and pockets it: "I nicked it, thinking that it might help me." He shows it to Flora and asks her to read it, telling her a lawyer can't be both good at the job and a good person.

Flora takes the stand, called by Morgan's side, and says that a man who came to the house offered to pay for her mother's conservatory, and that the man worked for Cathcarts. She never says his name. Then she brings up the letter herself and reads it aloud. In it, Morgan wants to end things "without these lawyers coming between us", and before the judge can rule, Morgan and Carla agree a settlement of their own.
Johnny also denies leaking the Flora story to the press, and the finale backs him up. The leak came from Zephyr's chief financial officer, Gillian Pope (Angel Coulby), who is about to be fired for it.
He goes home to find Bella gone and leaves her a letter. Then he goes back to Taylor & Byrne, where he is "persona non grata", and tells Serena he is sorry. She can hardly believe a word he says: "Tell me why I should." He answers: "'Cause I turned Flora around." He asks for a month to prove himself, then a fortnight, then a week, and Serena's contractions start in the middle of it. Her waters break later, in the lift with Nicholas. The season ends before she decides.
Should Serena give Johnny another chance?
The finale leaves Serena's answer open. I think she could, if he really has turned, and by the end of the season it did feel like he had. But he really has to prove himself. He needs to make amends, not a silly little apology, and put in the work. The case for him should come from someone else, maybe Flora, because only then does it make sense. The way everything has panned out, it doesn't make sense for Serena to give him another chance right now.
Bella, his girlfriend, is gone by the time he gets home in the finale, and honestly, he doesn't deserve a chance with her, if you think about it. He bailed out on her and looked out for himself, and he cheated on her with Carla. Sometimes it felt like he was just using her for a place to hang out. Relationships are complicated, though. He was a different person back then, and if he changes and puts in the work, maybe with a therapist's help, they could come back stronger. It won't be easy.
Is Johnny in War Season 2?
Yes. George Kay, who created the show, told The Hollywood Reporter that Johnny is "definitely a part of season two" and has to pay for some of his Season 1 decisions. He has also said Johnny is still "in play" as a lawyer, and that both firms now have reasons to turn him away: one was betrayed by him, and the other sees him as a liability. Season 2 is already filmed, and it gives the same two firms a new case, which Sky and HBO call "an explosive defamation case".
One casting detail points back to Johnny's past. Richard Schiff plays Elliott Wyatt in Season 2, the same name as the New York lawyer Cathcarts used to vouch for Johnny. Nobody has confirmed they are the same man. If they are, Season 2 brings in someone tied to the firm where Johnny's trouble began, who could reveal what he signed.
What I make of Johnny Warren
To me, Johnny is one of the worst of them all, and the most self-serving, though it isn't a competition: in War, everyone is first and everyone is last. He is smart, but he is one of those people who think they are better than everyone else, and he will use any means necessary. He damages just about everyone he touches: the firm he works for, the firm he feeds, Carla, and her friend Flora. Watching Smallwood catch him recording was great, because it shows Smallwood is not someone you can take advantage of easily. When Johnny started threatening Cathcarts, the story got more interesting: it felt like those untouchable lawyers could have something hanging around their necks. Honestly, all of these people deserve each other. They are the worst kind of people, at least as the show depicts them.
My guess about New York is that he did something like this there too, something he could have been disbarred for, and that is why he had to leave.
The ending felt strange to me. The show tries to give Johnny a good conclusion, and he didn't deserve one. Nothing before the finale suggested he would change at all, and then he does. Still, he isn't so different from everyone around him: Carla's side paid Flora off, and Morgan's side hired a mole. Everyone in War is out for themselves. My full review of War Season 1 covers the rest of the season.
